by Shaun Gray
Thursday night’s dramatic 3-2 comeback from Everton at Goodison Park against Crystal Palace stunted the universal rhetoric that Everton were destined for relegation this season. Admittedly, at times this was a very real possibility. The Toffees’ shortcomings have been pronounced all season long: a lack of defensive cohesion, plagued with individual errors leading to goals and abject when facing opposition set-pieces. Crystal Palace incessantly exposed that Bermuda Triangle of frailty in the first-half. A first-half that flirted with 10 minutes of fan-inspired optimism followed by being faced with a nigh on impossible prospect of cancelling out a 2-0 deficit at the interval. Heroics from Michael Keane, Richarlison and the rejuvenated Dominic Calvert-Lewin simultaneously quelled and reassured Everton supporters who had endured nothing short of a turbulent season.
One glaring point of contention is that viewpoint that Frank Lampard’s appointment has resulted in stalemate, he started his tenure in 16th and ended in 16th. Granted, if you are an outsider and look at this in isolation without any understanding of wider context, fair enough, it seems an uninspired appointment. However, coming into a football club that had won 3 of their last 18 games in all competitions was no simple task. Confidence was rock bottom, the ground atmosphere was abysmal and collective belief was that relegation was looming. Rafa Benitez ended his reign as manager of Everton Football Club at the foot of many statistical tables, serving to highlight the degenerative influence the controversial figurehead imposed over the club. Lets be frank, Lampard hasn’t miraculously cured years of financial mismanagement, poor recruitment and injury-prone personnel. Promisingly, what cannot be discounted is how much he has bought into the club ethos, he has instilled togetherness in the fan base and revitalised heavily maligned performers such as Alex Iwobi, who has arguably been our best player since Lampard took over. The notion that Everton’s manager ‘gets’ the club has been almost an unwritten requisite of the duty for decades. Ironically, this is something the board at Everton have got wrong consistently since Roberto Martinez was relieved of his duties in May 2016.
When you’ve got such a close-knit, historic football rivalry, (more so in proximity than in current footballing terms) appointing a manager who had once taken perch at Liverpool and croaked disdain towards the blue-half of Merseyside previously was always going to be met with a frosty reception. Everton fans live and breath their club and the culture of it. The cultural identity of Rafa Benitez was more pantomime villain, an absolute dichotomy with the perceived ‘ideal’ Everton manager. Alas, I do believe some supporters will have warmed to the idea when he won 3 of his first 4 Premier League games. What followed was a myriad of woe; Benitez became the manifestation of years of erroneous leadership of the club. Players earning inflated wages weren’t earning their keep, some weren’t available for selection enough simply because their torrid injury history clearly wasn’t identified by club scouts before their signings and Rafa isolated fan favourites James Rodriguez and Luca Digne who were darlings of the Carlo Ancelotti regime. The latter factor was inexplicable and arguably was the main cause of the poor goalscoring output this season (43) as Everton have been a toothless force that have massively lacked creativity and end-product. For Everton supporters, it was catharsis when now 20th placed Norwich comfortably defeated the Blues, resulting in the removal of Benitez’s borrowed robes as the King of Everton’s dugout. To think, reputable journalist and close friend of Rafa Benitez, Guillem Balague’s very vocal scrutiny on Twitter of the board’s decision and the fan’s reaction to Rafa’s appointment is one of the most fruitless displays of nepotism witnessed in recent history.
Spirits certainly began to raise after Alex Iwobi’s very, very late strike against Newcastle as the Toffees stuttered their resurgence under Eddie Howe. A series of chaotic and shambolic displays followed against Palace in the FA Cup and West Ham and fellow relegation fodder Burnley. At this stage, survival looked rather bleak with confidence levels again at rock-bottom. In many ways, it seemed befitting that Manchester United, who draw many disastrous defensive parallels in the upper-half of the table to Everton afforded victory thanks to a deflected Anthony Gordon effort. It was an almost uncharacteristically, resolute defensive display from the Toffees though. A late equaliser from Richarlison at the death against Leicester at home continued to repair damaged morale collectively. Predictably though, Liverpool took the spoils at Anfield despite every unsporting attempt to derail their superiority across the park. The pundit autopsy afterwards was cutting and critical of Everton, laughably so as the same spokespeople of the major broadcasters often herald Diego Simeone’s Atletico Madrid as ingenious despite evident similarity in styles. Double standards. Given the fixtures ahead of Everton and actually now sitting in a relegation spot in 18th, nervous energy was paramount among the loyal yet outwardly pessimistic following.
Dogged and resilient wins against Chelsea at home and Leicester away followed which appeared to ease some concerns in the most unlikeliest of circumstances. A win against Watford would have secured safety but rather inevitably, Everton limped to a 0-0 draw: Watford’s first point at home since battering Man United 4-1 in November. Dialogue certainly sparked after the controversial Brentford fixture, Richarlison and his blue cohort were outraged after a penalty appeal was turned down that almost certainly would have changed the tide of the game had that penalty been awarded and subsequently converted. In typical Everton fashion, Brentford were the beneficiaries of a decision to send the young, inexperienced Jarrad Branthwaite off who was the unfortunate Everton casualty of a cynical foul to combat a Brentford counter, directly after the shirt-pulling debacle in Brentford’s penalty area. Defeat came with anxiety levels raised as the Palace fixture loomed with memories of Patrick Vieira’s side giving Everton the runaround in the previous two encounters in the Premier League and FA Cup respectively. If the dismal first-half against Crystal Palace was anything to go off, pre-match nerves were wholly justified. What struck a chord the most was the nature of the final result – a group of players whose prior natural stasis was to be perilous to submission in high-stake, pressure situations – demonstrating an impertinent level of guile, vigor and substance that had been absent all season long. Any semblance of this was reverted to type once more against Arsenal at the Emirates on the final-day. A stark reminder that Lampard cannot rest on his laurels and that some serious work must be done in the summer.
In the aftermath of Thursday’s win against Palace, a lot was said of the fans bursting onto the pitch. Most comments appeared to snarl in the face of the euphoria demonstrated by the Everton’s fans – mooting that many were behaving like ‘they had won the league’. If relief that Premier League status is secured after an emphatic comeback is akin to celebrating a Premier League title then I’m sure Manchester City supporters who’ve seen the best and worse days for their club will be able to relate to this release of emotion. Views of that ilk are peddled by the ignorant who are increasingly fixated on the elitism at the top of the league. Arguably, this is a much wider issue in which football itself serves as a microcosm of the economic dynamics of the world, the wealthiest, most successful clubs dominate the media spotlight whereas very little credence or interest is taken in the clubs who don’t repeatedly achieve European finishes in their respective leagues. The undertones of said notion have been bubbling for a long-time on social media platforms and it quite blatantly dominates the press in this country. Wealth and most importantly the implementation of said wealth under a carefully planned recruitment structure is what is creating such a division between ‘elite’ clubs and the rest, in many ways this is why so many soulless cronies banded together to form a ‘Super League’ last year. Manchester City and Liverpool will continue to pull away from the rest of the league in that regard. Success is subjective. Success for those two (Premier League and Champions League wins, domestic cup domination) will always greatly contrast with the perceived success of Leeds and Everton this season who escaped relegation by a whisker. Expectations vastly differ. Premier League prize money is success within itself considering how plentiful it is for those who compete in the division. If you’re criticising celebrating survival in a division, chances are you support a club that has never had the displeasure of being involved in a relegation battle. Not every club can win a league year-in, year-out. Holistically, Everton will understandably see this season as an underwhelming and hugely disappointing season but the overarching point that must be made is that it was imperative that they survived in the Premier League as any blip could have potentially derailed ambitious plans to relocate to Bramley-Moore Dock Stadium at the start of the 2024/25 campaign.
Supporting Everton in the last 20 years yields a degree of acceptance that upheaval is part of the deal. Fighting for a European place has historically been met with some murmurs of discontent, even under the guidance of a pillar of consistency in David Moyes while narrowly avoiding relegation this campaign will understandably result in more prevalent criticism and condemnation of the club and the hierarchy above the manager’s remit. Everton fans are difficult to please as whole, as are many supporters of clubs with such gargantuan histories prior to the modern-Premier League era. Although Frank Lampard’s appointment was met with some apprehension, with many coining the decision ‘the best of a bad bunch’, Lampard has proven himself to be a real statesman and exemplar of ‘The People’s Club’. On merit for his role in uniting the evidently devoted romantics of the club, he should be given license, alongside newly appointed director of football, Kevin Thelwell to develop a strategic model for the club that embeds a longer-term vision in order to reinvigorate a squad of players that is ageing, overpaid and mentally fragile at times.